That Night with You, on the Rollercaster…

Hellmann was even funny and entertaining during the trial, but his best joke he made during the reading of the verdict…

The night to be loved, as we called it, didn’t exactly come as easy as one may think.

Hellmann and Zanetti, even the jurors, had given a clear sign during the trial… We were all sure the verdict would be of absolution, but… Hellmann kept us waiting that night…

He had said he would have come out “Not before 8 pm” but it was already 9, then it was 10…

THE VERDICT

Now it’s 10:30, maybe… What is going on? The mind almost starts fantasizing about a conflict going on in that chamber… I almost start to be worried. And you? Definitely, it seems: you enter the courtroom and you look in agony. And you keep agonizing while waiting for la corte to enter. Long, long minutes…
Then la corte, the destiny of your life –Hellmann, Zanetti and those faces with no voice, those sphinxes with their secret thoughts, who only stared at you from the top of the bench– enter.
A Fate to be Read
There is nothing to pray, or to hope, by now. Your fate has already been decided. It just has to be read.
You just have to know it. And knowing, this time, waiting for knowing, is the hardest thing.
Hellmann starts reading your fate… “This court… in partial reform of the previous sentence…” –So, it’s not “in reform of the previous sentence”. It’s “in partial reform”, we already know you haven’t been fully acquitted. And it could still be anything, maybe 21 years instead of 26– “…declares: Knox Amanda Marie colpevole…”
Damn, GUILTY AGAIN.
The curse is still on. The four year-long series of  “no”… “rejects”… “condemns”, continues.

But his speech goes on. “…of the crime of calunnia, and condemns her to the penalty of three years…”

Ah okay, he said  “la condanna”, “condemns her”, but just for the calunnia against Patrick, no big deal.

By the way, he had condemned you to three years, not to one year, as it was in the previous sentence, where that penalty was reduced due “continuation” with the main crime. So, he had considered the slander as an autonomous crime! That meant they had acquitted you for the murder!
Easy to say now. But this simple deduction was impossible to be done in those moments, when the words explode like bombs, or fireworks… when the time is dilated, when the mind is frozen, and only awaits the words that will mean either way: freedom or jail, life or no-life.

You have to suffer more, and we with you. A few seconds but, in truth… infinite moments in which you are set on the rack, suspended in a limbo.
Now he will speak about the main charge, now you will know.

It should be now. But Hellmann, cruel, keeps you waiting. While life seems to abandon your face, palest than ever, he starts reading all technicalities about the conviction for calunnia.
Even the technicalities! The calculation of how he got to three years!

When he’s over with that long reading he finally resumes: “….E la condanna….”.

Damn, he resumed and said LA CONDANNA, again! This time is for the murder, then!

It looks like that’s what you think now: that the curse is still on, that it will still be no-life.

Only for a fraction of second, though, because Hellmann continues: “…al pagamento delle spese…”. Ah okay. He was still speaking about the calunnia! Condemned again, yes, but to pay now, for Patrick’s compensation… The rollercaster of emotions sent you to the bottom rock and now pushes you up again. Damn hell man, he really wanted to give you a heart attack…

At this point finally Hellman has done with the calunnia and all its useless appendixes. And with his sadistic reading…

The jokes are over, now. Now he can only declare about the charge of homicide: Hellmann continues: “…Assolve entrambi gli imputati….” — “absolves both defendants”.
ASSOLVE, he said that! It’s the freedom! The end of the nightmare!

You can finally collapse in a big crying fit. Almost. You retain yourself, you want to listen, as Hellmann continues  “...per i  reati di…”, “…for the crimes of…”, and he lists all the charges: homicide: acquitted. Rape: acquitted….

It’s all a descent now. Just when you seemed to be lost, suddenly the series of “no”, the sequence of “condemns”, resounded for four years until a few seconds ago, is interrupted. Those ugly words, suddenly turned into their opposite, they became “yes”, they became, “acquits”, their meaning became “life”.

Words are no bombs this time, devastating the courtroom. Words are fireworks, are drops of honey, are the first swallow of fresh water after you’ve just crossed the desert.

Better crying in silence, as you are doing now, so that you can listen to every one of those words, just to be sure you are not in your cell, dreaming. Your mind couldn’t have invented those words in a dream. You are really hearing them, they are real!

And the fireworks continue: Theft: acquitted. Transportation of knife: acquitted. “For not having committed the fact”. Simulation of crime: acquitted. “Because the fact doesn’t exist”.

And the sweet words continue, up to the end, the sweetest end: “e  ne ordina l’immediata liberazione se non detenuti per altra causa”. “…and it orders their immediate release if not detained for other reason”.

It’s certain now, you are free.

Your crying can explode now. Carlo and Maria are consoling you, but there’s nothing to console. It only looks like you are desperate, but you are not (never trust appearances…): it’s happiness this time!

“I’m safe”, you look like thinking. You crossed the most dangerous battlefield, full of traps, snipers and traitors. After all those bullets, mines and bombs, exploding all around, the fire is over. It’s unbelievable, but you are alive!

The reading is over. La corte slowly trots away, and life returns to fulfill your face…
The ride is over on the nightmarish rollercoaster. Time to step on the ground, and return to real life.

Your amanda nox, your night to be loved, arrived for real, and it’s beautiful. Just as you, and someone else with you, dreamt it.

The moon stopped in the middle of the sky to shine it, the wind swept all clouds away to let the stars salute you, the summer has been waiting for you, to push you with a warm, soft breeze, on your way home.

He wasn’t the man of hell, he was really “the predestined”, der heller mann, who came to shed light on a big nonsense.
Four years, one life. It was just a big joke, a trip to middle ages, a bit long, but with return. A descent into the misery and the superstition of poor, sad, small people.
Your victory, on those people with a mask, those people with no power, no knowledge, was unavoidable. You should have seen the four of them, escaping in the night, like thieves, right after that he said “Assolve”. I had that privilege. Priceless…

SALVO. You didn’t know this…

And, since you are there, enjoy this too, Signorina…

Comments
    • pegleg2007 says:

      excellent post frank, i forgot to mention in my last post i did donate to your cause, as i know it takes time passion to sift through all the BS from the truths. it wasnt much, but, then every bit helps, I also donated to the defense fund back in 2009 and tried as often as possible to give when i had the $. Again evey bit helps!
      I agree with the others here, you should either write a book, (i will buy it) and hopefully a screeplay from the novel. If anything a consulting gig, i could envision, a movie something similar to the Julie and Julia. nothing like that cheap cheezie Lifetime movie. That movie was total junk, so much so, it hasnt played much here in the US which usually means not many people watched it or they couldnt get the sponsers on board becasue of the poor screenplay.
      Take care and keep up the good work!!!

  1. siennareid says:

    Beautiful Frank, absolutely beautiful. You really outdid yourself here. A perfect entry for your book!

  2. I have relived the moments of the verdict through your words, Frank. I agree: absolutely beautiful.

    The only difference: I sensed the acquittals on the more serious charges as the verdict was read, in part because the sentence for the calumnia was read first, and becasue the sentence was increased. The judge who had finally said “yes” was only getting the bad news out of the way first.

    Or maybe his joke was on the press who needed to send their reports out before the reading was finished?

  3. perugiashock says:

    Thank you!

    You sensed it?
    I didn’t in that moment…
    Also because next to me there was a journalist, one of those with a mask of good guy…
    As soon as he heard “condanna” he started jumping and yelling Si! Si!, all happy because she had been condemned… And he didn’t make me understand well…
    At least that night all masks feel down….

    This piece tries to relieve her own emotions and I don’t think she sensed she was acquitted because she heard 3 years…

    • struoc says:

      Frank you captured it exactly as I felt it.
      I find it interesting your experience was so different, and amazed people were jumping in glee of guilt.

      In the US was the interpreters missing words, interpreters skipping words, and overdubbing in English.. Guilty…Guilty….Guilty…I assumed she was found Guilty again. It was beyond intense somehow Guilty again? Then the confusion, acquitted. ..A,B.C,D…even the interpreters seemed
      confused, from the delivery of the charges.

      Days later, Curt Knox was on video mentioning that moment, he was saying “no!!” internally, because he didnt understand Amanda turning away to sob, on the Italian words…
      He said the English speaking lawyer said the unbelievable words, whatever they were exactly…then the fireworks and flee to secrecy.

      Then the news, the Kercher’s ask for clarity from this court system that disagrees with itself so strongly, because for them there were no fireworks.

      Rudy hides the truth, as he lies in Viterbo.

  4. perugiashock says:

    Btw, I think he declared the calunnia first because otherwise nobody would have listened to it….
    Really a bad joke…
    Especially for those who want to be the first, and run to write that she had been condemned…

  5. How true this is. Eloquently worded you hit it right on the nail.
    What was also amazing is that he declared she and Rafaele “not involved in this crime” rather than
    “not enough evidence to convict”! That was huge, in and of itself.

    Haters will hate, in their complete ignorance.
    And we….we will sleep in peace, knowing that sometimes the good guys DO win.
    What an amazing once in a life time opportunity to get to be involved in!
    It was great meeting you, and I want to encourage you to write write write!
    God’s given you a talent and I will look forward to see what happens with you.
    Perugia was beautiful, all of Italy was beautiful and the rats were caught in trap,
    to clean up the beautiful mid evil town of Perugia.

    Please update us on the “man of evil”. ;)
    ~michelle.

  6. ndalberth says:

    Frank,
    This is excellent, as always!
    I remember this moment, when the verdict was being read. My heart sank for one brief moment until I realized Hellman had moved on and I heard those wonderful words!
    Hellmann starts reading your fate… “This court… in partial reform of the previous sentence…” –So, it’s not “in reform of the previous sentence”. It’s “in partial reform”, we already know you haven’t been fully acquitted. And it could still be anything, maybe 21 years instead of 26– “…declares: Knox Amanda Marie colpevole…”

  7. Beyond excellent, Frank and beautifully written. BRAVO!

  8. Bravo Frank. Well done. Best piece of writing I have seen on the verdict.

  9. Maybe I sensed it because I wanted to believe it. Still, the rollercoaster analogy is perfect. It was so difficult to see her suffering through those moments.

  10. Great post Frank! It was the longest two or three minutes I have ever spent. Thanks for everything!!!

  11. randy2438 says:

    And so now Amanda sits jailed in her home kept there by tabloid reporters hoping to catch another money shot.

    Reporters not interested about the true story of how two innocent persons were held for 4 years because of the lies and the abusive power of a few prosecutors and police who will never pay for their crimes.

    That is a sad message for all of Italy because these thugs will remain free. No one will review these misdeeds because no one has the job to review the police or the prosecutors or the judges when they decide that the power they have is greater than the truth.

    Even Hellmann later gives a news conference and makes unusual claims how they could still be guilty and how he thinks the prosecution was correct and that he would do the same…
    And so he tries to save his face too.

    And so the pack of animals will remain free. The liars still own the courtroom. Stupid, even crazy ideas can again be freely made and no Italian dare question it…no news will write of it. The price is still too high and the real criminals are still in power.

    There is No Free Press in Italy…that is clear. And it can never happen as long as prosecutors are free to use unlimited resources of the peoples own money to make charges against those that try to tell the truth.

    Hellmann has shown us that he did the job he was assigned…end this mess and get us back to normal. And so that is what he has done. And so now Stefanoni can return to making up papers, Monica can return to forgetting to push record buttons, Mignini and his group of police and judges can continue covering for each others felonies…there is peace in pig town once more.

    And soon you will have the return of Rudy Guede to freedom and to your streets …perhaps Mignini will adopt him this time.

    Good job Perugia…sleep well.

  12. Beautifully written, Frank. Hellmann proved himself to be quite the impresario, setting in motion a fluid process that proceeded from the courtroom to the prison, the late-night convoy to Rome, the breathless tracking of the plane as it arced across the western hemisphere, and finally, a triumphant appearance at SeaTac airport.

    It was an artistic masterpiece, but the show is over. What will we stagehands do with our time?

  13. Elizabeth says:

    Show not quite over yet, Charlie.

    Waiting for the denouement:
    A. Mignini’s appeal
    B. Some sort of consequence(s) for the police in Perugia (or not)
    C. Amanda’s first public steps (as opposed to being Papped)
    D. Re-assurance that Raffaele is all right.
    E. The out come of the slander trials for Amanda and Knoxes
    F. Far in the future the outcome of last appeal.
    G. AND LAST BUT NOT LEAST, Frank’s two trials: one for beating up 5–yes FIVE–policemen (at once) when they politely knocked on his door one night, and the other, I believe, a trial for defamation of Mignini via his blog? (Not sure of that one.)

    Yes I never would have believed I’d get so absorbed in someone else’s story, and i feel such a huge relief that she and Raffaele are free, but the lose ends still interest and bother me.

    Frank, you still have lots to write about (including your book!)

  14. stogiechomper says:

    Frank, this is your best writing yet. You really captured the terror of that moment for Amanda, when her whole life was riding on the outcome. Excellent! You are a true warrior for truth and for justice, a man of great courage and principle, the best that Italy has to offer. We are all grateful that you were there to report for us the facts of this case. God bless!

  15. komponisto says:

    Wow, Frank, you really captured it here for me. I remember that my heart sank when I heard “parziale riforma”; I thought it was going to be some perfunctory sentence reduction (as in the case of Rudy).

    (Although, in fact, it was actually a “totale riforma”, because exactly nothing from the original decision was preserved: even the calunnia sentence was increased.)

    You seem to be the only one (besides me) to have noticed the significance of Amanda’s name. (Which is just beautiful!) And, for that matter, Hellmann’s.

    But there is one name you didn’t notice: the chief judge of Rudy’s Cassazione trial, who had the exact same first and last name as an Italian opera composer. Fitting, since there is something operatic about this whole story. (In fact, Night Is To Be Loved may make a good title…I speak as one whose pseudonym has a certain meaning…)

  16. ldpirozzi says:

    Nicely done, as usual.

    The four (the four of them, escaping in the night, like thieves):

    Mignini, Maresca, Stefanoni, Comodi ???? Other than spelling, how did I do?

    • perugiashock says:

      No, not them… They are known, they can’t escape… They have to stay in court until the end and receive their victory or their defeat… Then they have to exit from the main door, in front of everyone.

      The others. Those that people don’t know, those who have created all this disaster.
      Ask Amanda. She knows them…

  17. randy2438 says:

    My guess for the 4 thief’s who snuck off into the night are…

    Rita Ficarra
    Lorena Zugarini
    Monica Napoleone
    Domenico Giacinto Profazio

    Im not too smart…I dont understand the links at the end of the last article.

  18. laughingdogs says:

    Beautiful. Thank you.

    I hope Raffaele is okay. I am tempted to post a song for the signore as well.

  19. perugiashock says:

    You are almost there man…

  20. randy2438 says:

    Ok, I want to switch out Profazio and in his place goes Marco Chiaccheria

  21. g3ssycat says:

    Can anyone help Frank get a Publisher?

  22. g3ssycat says:

    Frank do you know about the article from the Enquirer….it says they have a source and they claim Rudy was going to meet with an eastern European guy who was a cocaine dealer …and that’s when Meridith arrived home, They claim this was not revealed back then because it would ruin Mignini’s theory…

  23. Now that they’re freed, you should channel your energy into something else. May I suggest a blog strictly devoted to Mignini and all his wacky antics. Suggested domain names:

    ItalianPorkyPig.com
    ChefBoyardee.org
    OutrageousAccusations.net
    MentallyUnstableDipshit.com
    DumbassOfPerugia.edu
    ElmerFudd.com
    TheHairClubForMen.com
    WeightWatchers.com
    PregnantMan.org

    • pigsticker says:

      (LOL), I think I’ll go with the “PregnantMan” domain for him. However, here’s a couple more ideas:

      BigFatLiar.com
      ClownOfPerugia.edu
      DictatorOfTheCourts.org
      Put_em_all_in_Jail.org
      Belongs_in_a_Straight_Jacket.com
      FatPsychoticPig.com

      Let me know if you think of any more…

      • pigsticker says:

        Actually, I just thought of something even better:

        MockeryOfJustice.org
        MediaManipulation.com
        MedievalWitchHunter.pig

        And for those interested in movies, we got “Liar Liar II”, in which one of Mignini’s defendants makes an honest man out of him, destroying his entire career (LOL).

  24. struoc says:

    Reading the articles today, when will we hear Rudy has been charged for severe, serious slander or defamation? Hopefully he will get the most severe additional years added, to correct the Fast Track mistake of the Perugia courts.

    6 more years might put Rudy back to 22yrs, closer to his initial 30yrs. If Amanda also files charges for Rudys defamtion, as Raffaeles lawyer said he would….then maybe 6 more years.

    Rudys lies and disgusting self interest still sits stagnating in his own sess pool of a life. The opportunistic criminal, Rudy Guede…. Justice would be served for him to get another 12yrs added by each Amanda and Raffaele.

  25. How are you doing now that all of the drama has died down. And are you perusing an agent? Hope you are well,
    ~m.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s